SUFAS Educational Consultants

Policy Consequences

10 original prompts with writing plans, model answers and space to draft.

Approach this task direction

  1. State the policy’s intended effect and who would be affected.
  2. Trace how the rule could produce a benefit and an unintended cost.
  3. Weigh those consequences and explain the conditions or safeguards that shape your position.

Common mistake

Naming possible effects is a start. Show how the policy could cause each effect and why its importance changes your decision.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1 · The Nine O’Clock Bell

School boards should require secondary schools to begin lessons no earlier than nine o’clock in the morning.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. State when a nine o’clock start would be worth adopting.
  2. Follow the change from the bus timetable to a pupil’s first lesson.
  3. Consider how a later finish could affect care and extracurricular activities.
  4. Explain which local constraints would justify an exception.

Useful language

Verbs in context

shift start times · coordinate transport · accommodate family schedules

Phrases to adapt

  • “A later start could benefit pupils who … if transport arrangements allow them to …”
  • “A uniform start time could create difficulties for families whose schedules depend on …”
0 words
Show model answer

A bell at nine o’clock can give some pupils a chance to arrive ready to learn. Its effect depends on when pupils have to leave home and on where the displaced time goes. I favour a nine o’clock start for secondary schools that can shift transport alongside lessons, with discretion for boards that would otherwise create a serious obstacle to attendance.

Consider a pupil who catches a bus before seven to reach an eight o’clock lesson. If the bus and the lesson both move later, the pupil can wake later while keeping the same bedtime. An extra hour at home can also make time for breakfast. If the bus keeps its old timetable, however, the same pupil may spend the extra hour waiting at school. The benefit comes from changing the whole journey.

A later finish shifts costs onto families whose afternoons are already tightly scheduled. A pupil who collects a younger sibling from primary school may lose the ability to do so. A sports team that relies on daylight could have a shorter practice. Moving an activity to lunchtime might help the team, but replacing a regular carer can be much harder. A board should give particular weight to disruptions that affect whether a pupil can attend at all.

In a district where buses can run later and most families can manage the new finish, a board could offer a supervised early room for pupils whose parents still need to drop them off before work. A district that shares buses with several primary schools has fewer options. A later secondary route might leave younger pupils waiting for vehicles or require more buses than the district can provide.

A board should therefore plan transport and supervision before setting the new timetable and examine lateness and missed lessons after the change. Nine o’clock is a reasonable default where it genuinely gives pupils a later morning. Where a board can show that the timetable would make regular attendance harder, it should be able to retain an earlier start.

Show rationale

The essay tests whether a later bell changes the time pupils actually have to wake up. It traces the effect through bus timetables, family schedules and afternoon activities, then uses those consequences to support a nine o’clock start where boards can preserve access and to justify exceptions where they cannot.

Prompt 2 · Assessment Criteria in Advance

Universities should require lecturers to publish the marking rubric for each assignment when they set it.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Defend publishing the rubric with the assignment.
  2. Show how shared criteria can change a student’s decisions during revision.
  3. Explain how a rigid rubric could distort student work.
  4. Connect the benefits and drawbacks to the design of the rubric.

Useful language

Verbs in context

publish assessment criteria · clarify expectations · prevent formulaic responses

Phrases to adapt

  • “Early access to the rubric would help students focus on …”
  • “If the criteria are too prescriptive, students may give less attention to …”
0 words
Show model answer

A student can devote days to an assignment while misunderstanding what the lecturer expects. Publishing the marking rubric when the task is set gives students a chance to use that information while it can still influence their work. Universities should require advance publication because it makes the expectations available to everyone and gives lecturers a reason to make those expectations precise.

Suppose a history student is asked to compare two accounts of a strike. The student might assume that a detailed summary of both accounts will earn a good mark. A rubric that values evaluating sources would prompt a different plan. The student could ask who wrote each account, when it was written and what evidence each author could see. Such information is especially valuable to someone who has yet to learn the conventions of university history.

The policy also changes what lecturers have to do. In a course with several markers, preparing the rubric before the assignment goes out can expose disagreements early. One marker might expect an original thesis, while another might reward a careful treatment of an established argument. Discussing those expectations before students start gives the teaching team time to resolve the difference and reduces the chance that the assigned marker determines the result.

An overly prescriptive rubric can create a different problem. If an essay earns points for using three sources or for placing a counterargument in a particular paragraph, students may make those choices even when they weaken the argument. A rubric can instead reward the relevance of the evidence and the quality of the response to objections. Those criteria are specific enough to guide revision and flexible enough to accommodate several strong approaches.

Writing a good rubric takes time, especially when a course introduces a new kind of assignment. Lecturers already have to decide what deserves credit, and stating those decisions early makes them available for discussion. Advance publication is worth the effort because it lets students act on expectations that would otherwise reach some of them only when the marks arrive.

Show rationale

The essay follows the policy from a student’s reading of an assignment to choices about research and revision. It weighs the risk that a checklist could encourage formulaic work and explains why that consequence calls for carefully written criteria while leaving the case for advance publication intact.

Prompt 3 · Rotas Two Weeks Ahead

Employers should be required to publish work rotas for hourly staff at least fourteen days in advance.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Argue for a two-week publication deadline.
  2. Show why earlier notice affects arrangements for care and other commitments.
  3. Consider how an employer would handle fluctuating demand and sudden absences.
  4. Explain how the policy could retain useful flexibility.

Useful language

Verbs in context

publish rotas in advance · stabilise working hours · accommodate staffing gaps

Phrases to adapt

  • “Advance notice would allow hourly staff to plan … with greater certainty.”
  • “The rule would need a clear exception when unforeseen absences …”
0 words
Show model answer

When an employer sets next week’s rota on Friday, the business can respond to recent demand. Its workers have to keep much of the coming week open while they wait. A fourteen-day publication requirement would give hourly staff time to organise commitments that depend on other people. Employers should meet that deadline even though some businesses would have to change how they plan for busy periods.

Imagine a supermarket worker who shares childcare with a partner. If both know their shifts a fortnight ahead, they can work out which days each can collect their child and arrange help for the days that overlap. A Friday notice for a Monday evening shift leaves fewer options. A relative may already have plans, and a colleague who might have swapped shifts may have made arrangements of their own. The added notice gives several people time to coordinate.

An employer also has a legitimate need to adjust. A café might find out that a street festival is expected to draw a crowd on Saturday. Committing to a rota early means either allowing some room for a busy day or asking for extra cover later. Some staff may welcome an additional shift. Others may have made commitments based on the posted hours, and they should be able to decline without losing their usual work.

Publication would achieve little if managers could routinely rewrite the rota at short notice. A sensible implementation would make the published rota the working plan, allow staff to request swaps and permit managers to ask for volunteers when demand changes. When an emergency forces a change, recording the reason would help distinguish a rare disruption from a pattern of avoidable last-minute scheduling.

Planning earlier can cost a business some flexibility, and the cost will be greater where demand is hard to predict. The same uncertainty currently reaches workers as a constraint on their time away from work. A fortnight’s notice gives them a fair chance to plan and still leaves employers room to handle the occasions when forecasts fail.

Show rationale

The essay identifies how advance notice transfers some uncertainty from workers to employers and makes the practical gains visible through a childcare example. It tests the rule against sudden absences and changing demand, then explains why voluntary swaps and limited emergency changes help preserve the benefit of the published rota.

Prompt 4 · Walk-In Library Computers

Public libraries should reserve half of their public computers for walk-in use.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Explain why walk-in access matters to patrons with limited connectivity.
  2. Compare the effect of a half-and-half split at two contrasting branches.
  3. Trace what happens when capacity sits idle on either side.
  4. Defend a local allocation rule that preserves both types of access.

Useful language

Verbs in context

reserve walk-in slots · allocate booking capacity · monitor unmet demand

Phrases to adapt

  • “A walk-in allocation is especially useful for patrons who cannot …”
  • “A fixed split could leave terminals idle at branches where most users …”
0 words
Show model answer

On a morning when a library is busy, a computer reservation can save a patron an hour of waiting. The ability to reserve that computer can itself depend on having a device, a connection or time to call during opening hours. Libraries should protect walk-in access, but the proposed half-and-half split assumes that branches face the same kinds of demand. They have good reason to set different allocations.

In a branch next to a job centre, several patrons might come straight from appointments to complete online forms. They may have learnt what they need to do only minutes before arriving. If most computers have been booked in advance, an open terminal can determine whether a visitor finishes the task before catching the bus home. Holding a share of stations for arrivals helps people who have had little opportunity to plan.

At a small branch in a village, a patron might make a special trip to use a computer and need to know that a station will be free. Imagine that the branch has two computers and that only one can be booked. Two patrons may want an appointment during the same hour. The second may decide to stay home, even though the walk-in station remains empty. The rule has then protected a vacancy at the cost of a visit.

A branch could choose an initial split and adjust it using observations of queues, unfilled slots and booking requests it cannot meet. It could also allow a short session at an idle reserved terminal if the session ends before the booking starts. Those measures would require staff to explain the rules clearly, since patrons need to know what they can count on before they travel.

The policy rightly recognises that requiring a booking can put a barrier in front of the people who most need a public computer. A guarantee of some walk-in access addresses that problem. Local allocations give a library the chance to make that guarantee meaningful without wasting scarce computer time where scheduled use is especially important.

Show rationale

The essay examines how the same allocation changes waiting and access in two different branches. It gives concrete reasons people rely on each kind of booking, then uses idle capacity and unmet demand to explain why the library system should guarantee walk-in access while letting branches set the share locally.

Prompt 5 · Delivery Bays on Shopping Streets

City councils should convert one kerbside parking space on every commercial block into a shared delivery bay.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Identify the street problem that a delivery bay could solve.
  2. Compare the consequences on two blocks with different delivery patterns.
  3. Explain how bay length, access and enforcement affect the result.
  4. Use the comparison to decide where councils should convert spaces.

Useful language

Verbs in context

allocate kerbside space · reduce double-parking · enforce loading limits

Phrases to adapt

  • “A designated bay could reduce double-parking by allowing delivery drivers to …”
  • “Converting a space on every block may displace … in areas where …”
0 words
Show model answer

On a narrow shopping street, a van stopped in a traffic lane can delay a bus and force people on bicycles to move around it. A delivery bay gives the driver a place to pull over. That benefit is a good reason to create bays on some streets. Applying the same rule to every commercial block would overlook how deliveries already happen and how much a block depends on its existing kerbside space.

Take a block with a bakery, a café and a small grocer. Several suppliers arrive before the shops open, when staff can receive goods. If a bay lets one van unload clear of the traffic lane, the benefit extends beyond the shop receiving the goods. If the vehicles arrive together, though, the second driver will still need somewhere to stop. A council might need to find a longer bay or work with businesses on staggering deliveries.

Now consider a block whose shops receive stock through a rear service entrance. A new bay out front may sit empty most mornings while removing a convenient space near a repair shop. A customer collecting a heavy item could have to walk farther with it. If the block already has few convenient places to stop, that loss is real even when the policy removes just one space.

The council also has to make the bay usable. Some vans will extend beyond a single parking space, and a bay close to a crossing may make it harder to see people stepping into the road. If cars can occupy the bay during delivery hours with little chance of being moved, drivers may continue to double-park. Siting and keeping the bay clear are part of achieving the result the conversion promises.

Councils should identify where deliveries routinely obstruct other street users and convert spaces where a bay can realistically ease that problem. On a street with concentrated morning deliveries, the council could restrict the space to loading during those hours and permit short stays later. A targeted approach preserves the strongest benefit of the proposal while accounting for the uses a bay displaces.

Show rationale

The essay tests a uniform policy against the actual movement of goods and people on two plausible streets. It explains why reducing double parking on one block could justify the change while an unused bay on another would remove valuable access, then connects the conclusion to demand, design and enforcement.

Prompt 6 · First Solo Exhibitions

Publicly funded galleries should reserve half of their solo exhibition slots for artists who have never held a solo exhibition.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Explain how a first solo show can change an artist’s opportunities.
  2. Test the eligibility rule against two artists with different exhibition histories.
  3. Trace the incentive the rule creates for accepting smaller shows.
  4. Use those effects to argue for an alternative way to widen access.

Useful language

Verbs in context

reserve exhibition slots · broaden access · support emerging artists

Phrases to adapt

  • “A guaranteed share could give first-time exhibitors access to …”
  • “An inflexible quota could make programming harder in seasons when …”
0 words
Show model answer

A publicly funded gallery can give an artist time, space and an audience that would be hard to assemble independently. Reserving half of its solo exhibitions for first-time exhibitors would open a route into the programme, and that goal deserves support. The proposed eligibility test, however, would make a small previous show count against artists whose access to professional exhibition space is still limited.

The attraction of the policy is clear. An artist who has displayed individual pieces in group exhibitions might finally get the room to show how a series fits together. A gallery can also document the show, giving the artist material to share with curators elsewhere. A reserved share of the programme would encourage a selection panel to look beyond applicants with a long record of comparable exhibitions.

The category of first-time exhibitor is a poor measure of who needs that opportunity. One artist may have displayed work alone for a week in a community hall. Another may have shown regularly in prestigious group exhibitions and already know several gallery directors. The second artist could compete for the reserved slots. The first would have to seek a place in the smaller general programme. If a small solo show closes off a chance at a much better equipped venue, artists may even decline modest opportunities to preserve their eligibility.

Giving a debut a privileged place can also leave little attention for what happens afterwards. An artist may need a second show to develop an idea first presented in a single room. A gallery that can stage two solo exhibitions a year would have at most one opening for anyone who has already had a show. Its public role includes taking a chance on new artists and giving some of them the space to grow.

Galleries should set aside opportunities for artists who have had limited access to professionally supported solo shows and judge applications in light of the support each applicant has already received. That approach asks panels to explain their judgements. It also rewards experience gained in small venues and directs support towards the artists the proposal is trying to reach.

Show rationale

The essay follows the quota beyond the immediate allocation of gallery space. It compares a large debut with a small earlier show, identifies an incentive to turn down opportunities and considers the importance of follow-on exhibitions. Those consequences lead it to reject the eligibility test while supporting a deliberate opening for artists with limited access.

Prompt 7 · Theatre Beyond the City Centre

Publicly funded theatres should stage at least one production each season in a venue outside the city centre.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Link venue location to the time and effort of attending a show.
  2. Work through an example of a neighbourhood production.
  3. Consider central transport links and the costs of adapting a show.
  4. Explain how venue and production choices affect your support for the rule.

Useful language

Verbs in context

extend a theatre's geographic reach · adapt a production to a venue · budget for touring

Phrases to adapt

  • “A production outside the centre could reach people who …”
  • “The benefit depends in part on whether the venue can accommodate …”
0 words
Show model answer

A person who can reach a theatre after work may still decide against going if the journey home is long or uncertain. Publicly funded theatres should stage at least one production outside the city centre each season. A local venue can make a performance feasible for people who rarely attend, provided the theatre chooses a site and a production that fit each other.

Consider an evening performance in a district with a community hall near several housing estates. A parent who would need to arrange three hours of childcare for a city-centre show might be able to attend a show within walking distance. A local choir that uses the hall may also be able to tell its members about the production. The shift in venue reduces the effort of attending and can bring news of the show to people the theatre rarely reaches.

Distance from the centre is an imperfect guide to access. A central venue may sit near routes that converge from several districts, while a suburban venue can be hard to reach from the other side of the city. Moving every performance would put some existing audiences at a disadvantage. The scale of this proposal matters. A theatre can extend its reach for one production while giving its regular audiences plenty of opportunities to attend centrally.

Staging a show in a hall also creates work for the host and the theatre. A production built around heavy scenery may require costly alterations or crowd out regular users during a long installation. A theatre can limit that burden by planning the production with the host from the start and choosing a script and staging that suit the available space. The host can also help pick dates when the hall can accommodate rehearsals and performances.

The seasonal requirement is justified because it gives theatres a reason to build relationships outside their usual catchment. Its success depends on where the venue is, whom it serves and what it can support. A season planned with those conditions in mind can make theatre easier to attend for people whose options are currently limited.

Show rationale

The essay assesses how moving a production changes access for audiences and working conditions for theatres and host venues. It considers who gains and who could face a harder journey, then uses the consequences of transport, production design and local collaboration to support a carefully chosen production outside the centre each season.

Prompt 8 · Name-Blind Shortlisting

Employers should replace applicants’ names with identification numbers when screening written job applications.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Limit the argument to the initial review of written applications.
  2. Show how name removal could change a borderline decision.
  3. Consider proxy cues, identifiable work samples and administrative effort.
  4. Explain why the expected change is still worth making.

Useful language

Verbs in context

anonymise applications · reduce initial bias · standardise screening

Phrases to adapt

  • “Masking names could reduce the influence of assumptions about … during screening.”
  • “The effect would be limited if later selection decisions still depend on …”
0 words
Show model answer

Shortlisting determines whose qualifications an employer will have a chance to explore in an interview. At that stage, a reviewer may have only a few minutes per application, and a familiar surname can draw attention before the reviewer reaches the work history. Employers should replace names with numbers during the written review. The policy can improve a consequential early decision with a modest change to the materials reviewers receive.

Imagine two applicants for an engineering apprenticeship. Both describe the same level of practical experience, but the reviewer recognises one surname from a local business and assumes that applicant already understands the trade. With names replaced, the reviewer has to look for evidence in the examples each applicant gives. The two people may still receive different scores, but the difference is more likely to come from something relevant to the work.

Other clues will remain. A reviewer may infer where someone grew up from a school name or recognise a byline on a submitted article. Trying to remove every clue could take considerable staff time and strip useful context from applications. An editor applying for a job should be able to explain their responsibility for a published piece. Employers could let applicants provide plain-text excerpts or describe their contributions, with administrative staff retaining the original materials for later verification.

Applicants will also have to identify themselves at an interview, and impressions formed then can shape the outcome. Even so, an applicant who reaches that stage can answer a technical question or explain an unfamiliar qualification. Someone screened out on paper loses the chance to provide that evidence. The first round matters precisely because later decisions can take account of more information.

The extra work is manageable when an application system gives reviewers a copy with names replaced and keeps a separate record for contacting candidates. Employers can then use the same selection criteria on each copy. The policy deserves support because it gives reviewers one fewer irrelevant cue at the stage when a quick judgement can end an application.

Show rationale

The essay identifies the particular hiring decision the policy could improve and traces how it could affect an applicant’s chance of reaching an interview. It weighs other identity cues and the burden of redacting work samples, then explains why a limited intervention can be worthwhile even though bias can recur later.

Prompt 9 · Food Scrap Collection in Flats

Municipal waste departments should collect food scraps separately from general rubbish at every block of flats.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Take a position on extending collection to every block of flats.
  2. Trace the route from the kitchen to a facility that can use the scraps.
  3. Compare the practical barriers in two kinds of building.
  4. Explain how those barriers should affect the roll-out.

Useful language

Verbs in context

separate food scraps · prevent contamination · adapt collection to building layouts

Phrases to adapt

  • “Separate collection will work best where residents can reach … easily.”
  • “A uniform rule could be costly to implement in blocks that lack …”
0 words
Show model answer

When residents in flats put food scraps into a shared rubbish bin, the waste department collects them with the rest of the building’s rubbish. A dedicated collection makes it possible to send those scraps to a facility that can turn them into compost. Municipalities should extend that service to every block of flats, with collection starting at each building once there is a workable bin location and a destination for the material.

A modern block with a spacious bin store might be able to add a food bin beside the general rubbish containers. Residents can use both on the same trip downstairs. If the food bin is close and its purpose is clear, separating leftovers becomes a small addition to a familiar routine. A collection vehicle can then take scraps from several buildings to a site that is set up to handle them.

An older block may have a narrow courtyard where the existing bins already leave little room. A new bin could block a walkway, and if the only alternative location is hard to reach, some residents will keep using the nearest container. Confusing signs or infrequent collections can make the problem worse. Once a shared bin contains a mixture the receiving facility cannot handle, residents’ efforts may yield little benefit and their willingness to sort scraps may decline.

The service also requires more than space at each building. A waste department may have to organise a separate collection route and confirm what its receiving facility accepts. Opening a collection in every building at once could leave staff trying to resolve unsuitable bin sites and mixed loads across the city. A staged roll-out would let the department address the problems at an initial group of buildings and apply those lessons to the next group.

Leaving difficult blocks outside the service indefinitely would deny residents there a practical way to separate scraps. The department should set a citywide timetable and work with building managers on layouts and collection arrangements. Universal coverage is worth pursuing because the collection can divert usable material from general rubbish when every part of the service works.

Show rationale

The essay traces the policy through the entire collection chain and shows where its intended effect can fail. Contrasting a modern bin store with a cramped communal area makes the implementation trade-off concrete. The conclusion uses those consequences to defend universal coverage as a goal with a phased start tied to collection and processing capacity.

Prompt 10 · Swimming Lessons by Lottery

Public leisure centres should allocate places in oversubscribed beginners’ swimming classes by lottery.

Task direction

Give your position on the proposed policy. Analyse likely consequences of putting it into practice and explain which consequences matter most to your judgement.

Writing plan and useful language
  1. Show how first-come registration distributes scarce places.
  2. Explain how a lottery with a registration window changes who can compete.
  3. Address cancellations and repeated unsuccessful applications.
  4. Defend your position using the consequences for access and attendance.

Useful language

Verbs in context

allocate places by lottery · give applicants an equal chance · prioritise unmet need

Phrases to adapt

  • “A lottery would reduce the advantage enjoyed by applicants who can …”
  • “An equal chance of selection could still leave … underserved if …”
0 words
Show model answer

When a popular beginners’ swimming class opens for registration at noon, a parent who can pause work to log in has an advantage over one who can get online only in the evening. The difference says little about who can attend the class or who would benefit from it. Public leisure centres should use a lottery for oversubscribed classes and give applicants several days to enter.

Under that arrangement, a shift worker could submit a request after coming home and have the same chance as someone who enters as soon as registration opens. The centre could also take entries by telephone, since staff would have several days to speak with callers and the draw would treat their entries the same as online submissions. The change would cost applicants some certainty. A family that previously secured a place immediately would have to wait until the draw to know whether it could plan around that class.

A lottery could also increase the number of places initially offered to people who later discover they cannot use them. A parent might apply for several times while arranging transport, then accept only one offer. The centre can ask applicants to list sessions they could attend, give each successful applicant one place and keep a waiting list in the order drawn. When a place is declined, staff can offer it promptly to the next applicant for that session.

Repeated draws could still leave a family without a place for several terms. A centre could give applicants who missed out in the previous round a separate draw for a portion of the places. That would give persistent applicants a better chance while leaving places available to newcomers. Records of unmet demand could also show whether an extra class at a particular time would make better use of the pool.

A lottery cannot create more teaching space on its own. It can remove the advantage of being available at a particular minute and give the centre a clearer view of demand. With a waiting list and some provision for repeat applicants, that is a fairer way to allocate a limited public service.

Show rationale

The essay compares two allocation mechanisms through the people each would advantage. It traces the lottery’s effects on access, certainty and attendance, including how a waiting list could fill vacated places. It then ties its support to safeguards for families who repeatedly miss out and to demand information the centre can use.